Ukraine Peace: An America First Peace Through Strength Compendium

Nathan R. Price
January 19, 2025

Mr. Price was a former Afghanistan analyst and peacemaker at the U.S. Department of State, where he helped deliver a peace deal on behalf of President Trump to end the war in Afghanistan. Price was one of a handful of individuals involved in the most sensitive planning efforts. He counts 11 years’ diplomatic experience, most within the Bureau of Intelligence & Research, where the rubber meets the road on intelligence and policy.

Contents

On Staffing
Part I – America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine

On Space-based Confidence Building
Part II – PAX: Winning Ukraine Peace Through U.S. Space Dominance

On Managing Interagency Rivalries
Part III – Gentlemen, you can’t fight in here. This is the War Room!

Bearing Witness to the Dangers of Ballistic Missiles
Part IV – Putin Fires Missile Barrage in First Post-election Left Hook
Re-printed for public release courtesy the Ben Franklin Fellowship

A Call to the Stars
Part V – Remember Apollo

Moving in, Moving Out
Part VI – Ad Astra

Dear Reader:

I hope with all my heart that these ideas may inspire and enable you to find peace for America and the world in the future. My ideas are informed by direct experience on a prior concluded peace deal—but all deals are different. If you take nothing else from these notions, remember this: America is counting on you. Count on those next to you.

It is in this spirit that I owe a debt of gratitude to David Baker, Joseph Cutler, Andy Baker, and Phillip Linderman, who have endeavored to advance American interests throughout.

These ideas—good or bad—are (mostly) mine, but these friends and others unnamed have provided faithful feedback, as well as patient advice throughout. Thanks for open minds.

To the Stars.

-NRP, 1/19/2025

America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine

The Trump Campaign should be prepared to build a small U.S.-led peace negotiations team to end the war in Ukraine upon assuming office, and its structure should be informed by lessons learned from the past U.S.-Taliban peace negotiations that delivered a deal.

The war is a great power struggle between the United States and Russia in a Ukrainian battlespace. Negotiations should therefore begin after U.S. inauguration bilaterally between Washington and Moscow, with NATO and Ukraine following U.S. lead.

Planning is urgent because of the risk of thermonuclear war in the event of a miscommunication between the United States and Russia—particularly the possibility of a misunderstood missile exchange in the Ukraine combat area that now includes Russia.

The U.S. peace team structure should meet three core criteria:

  1. Be small enough to defend against foreign intelligence.

The core group should be limited to around five, including chief negotiator. The broader office should be no more than 10-15 personnel for max agility while ensuring tight security.

  1. Work at a high U.S. echelon while preserving space for decision escalation.

I recommend OVP leadership for control while still allowing escalation to POTUS. Other structural options include an NSC office or State special envoy office.

  1. Include top U.S. policy, intelligence, and military special operations elements.

I recommend the core group be (1) OVP, (2) NSC, (3) State, (4) CIA, and (5) JSOC:

  • Policy. OVP and NSC are necessary to ensure policy alignment with POTUS.

  • Diplomacy. State is needed to manage public affairs, NATO alliance engagement, and Ukrainian sovereign expectations.

  • Operations. CIA and JSOC provide special capabilities while ensuring U.S. intelligence and U.S. military buy-in.

Precise format, redlines, sequencing, mediation, and location are beyond the scope of this white paper, which does not represent official U.S. policy. Its views are the author’s alone.

PAX: Winning Ukraine Peace Through U.S. Space Dominance
Part II to America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine, July 12, 2024.

We choose to go to the Moon...and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard. - JFK, September 12, 1962.¹

The Cold War is over, but a Hot War has replaced it in Ukraine. Risk of nuclear annihilation is the highest since 1947, according to the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists.² To deescalate, we should undertake a grand plan: ground peace through space dominance.

  • Preventing thermonuclear war over Ukraine is prerequisite to becoming a starfaring civilization. Elon Musk calls WWIII a “civilizational risk we may not recover from.”³

  • The Apollo Program resulted from the Cold War arms race between the United States and the Soviet Union—both nations had to prove their missile technology.⁴

  • We peacefully beat Russia to the moon in 1969, proving that destructive forces can be harnessed for good to move America and mankind forward.⁵ We can do it again.

PAX is a three-point framework to enable peace in Ukraine through visionary leadership:

  1. We publicly dare Russia to a Mars space race on X.com.⁶ This shifts tensions away from Ukraine and sets conditions for peace, which Zelensky supports.⁷

This is President Trump’s legacy. America wants to believe in something besides combat in the mud on the plains of Ukraine that could trigger nuclear Armageddon.

  1. President Trump, RFK Jr. and Elon explain the race vs. fight logic on X.

We race in space, not fight on earth. The message is simple. RFK Jr. invokes his uncle JFK’s space race “brand,” and Elon on September 7 already set a Mars Starship launch target in two years during the next Earth-Mars transfer window.⁸,⁹

  1. Elon could suggest a space expert for our Ukraine peace team. This would prove our intent to shift the East-West great power rivalry peacefully into space.

We get it done. Musk wants to lead a Government Efficiency program, but his vast responsibilities and footprint preclude detailed involvement in Ukraine peace.¹⁰

  • A Silicon Valley representative could eventually resign to join. This would make our approach innovative.

The format of peace negotiations is beyond the scope of this white paper, which does not represent official U.S. or Trump Campaign policy. Its views are the author’s alone.

Sources

1 “Address at Rice University on the Nation’s Space Effort | JFK Library,” accessed September 8, 2024, jfklibrary.org/learn/about-jfk/historic-speeches/address-at-rice-university-on-the-nations-space-effort.

2 John Mecklin, “2023 Doomsday Clock Statement,” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, January 24, 2023, thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/2023-doomsday-clock-statement.

3 Alex Backus, “Elon Musk Says ‘Avoiding’ World War III Is the ‘Most Important Issue,’” Newsweek, October 24, 2023, newsweek.com/elon-musk-world-war-iii-discussion-1837571.

4 “What Was the Space Race?,” National Air and Space Museum, August 23, 2023, airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/what-was-space-race.

5 “Apollo 11 - NASA,” accessed September 8, 2024, nasa.gov/mission/apollo-11.

6 “2024 GOP Platform: Make America Great Again!,” July 8, 2024, 9, gop.com/press-release/icymi-rnc-platform-committee-adopts-2024-republican-party-platform.

7 “Zelensky’s Peace Plan to Be Presented to Biden, Harris, Trump,” accessed September 9, 2024, thehill.com/policy/international/4851677-zelensky-presents-peace-plan.

8 Elon Musk [@elonmusk], “Free Speech Is the Foundation of Democracy,” X Tweet, X.Com, August 31, 2024, x.com/elonmusk/status/1829778285561065758.

9 Elon Musk [@elonmusk], “The First Starships to Mars Will Launch in 2 Years When the next Earth-Mars Transfer Window Opens. These Will Be Uncrewed to Test the Reliability of Landing Intact on Mars. If Those Landings Go Well, Then the First Crewed Flights to Mars Will Be in 4 Years [...],” X Tweet, X.Com, September 7, 2024, x.com/elonmusk/status/1832550322293837833.

10 Elon Musk [@elonmusk], “@JTLonsdale Joe, Perhaps You Would Be Interested in Joining the Dept of Govt Efficiency Https://T.Co/7yKQLban1B,” [blocked] X Tweet, X.Com, September 8, 2024, x.com/elonmusk/status/1832853069786452472.

Ukraine Peace: Gentlemen, you can’t fight in here. This is the War Room!
Part III to America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine, July 12, 2024.

America First Teaming to bring peace to Ukraine requires U.S. military leaders respect the lawful authority of the duly elected U.S. President, otherwise our republic is undermined, and peace beyond reach. Vice President-elect Vance as President Trump’s right hand and a Marine veteran is well positioned to lead a respectful reset this Veteran’s Day.

The job of generals is to run wars. The job of statesmen is to end them. Any man off the American street knows this. Recent domestic news implies U.S. generals need a reminder.

  • On Friday, November 8, CNN reported anonymous Pentagon officials convened at some point about how to react to President-elect Trump. “We are all preparing and planning for the worst-case scenario, but the reality is that we don’t know how this is going to play out yet,” one defense official said.¹

  • On Friday, November 8, Reuters exclusively reported that the Biden-Harris Administration greenlit provision of U.S. defense contractors on the ground inside Ukraine, “in a significant policy shift that aims to aid Kyiv’s fight against Russia.”²

  • On Friday, November 8, Politico reported “Defense officials are getting anxious about the possibility of the incoming Trump administration firing Joint Chiefs Chair Gen. C.Q. Brown, due to perceptions that he is out of step with the president-elect on the Pentagon’s diversity and inclusion programs.”³

Risk of Accidental Spiral

The salvo of press on the same day could be coincidental, or may imply a coordinated press messaging campaign from current Pentagon officials. Either way, if Pentagon concerns fester unaddressed, there is risk of a downward spiral in U.S. civil-military relations, which would disrupt a unified U.S. peace negotiations strategy with Russia.

A Structural Pattern

Infighting between U.S. diplomats and generals delayed peace negotiations in Afghanistan for years, impacting both President Obama and President Trump’s prior administrations. In this sense the problem is structural, providing a possible rhetorical frame of reference. Veteran’s Day is a perfect symbolic moment to intercede and reset relations.

¹ Natasha Bertrand and Haley Britzky, “Pentagon Officials Discussing How to Respond If Trump Issues Controversial Orders | CNN Politics,” CNN, November 8, 2024, cnn.com/2024/11/08/politics/pentagon-officials-discussing-trump/index.html.

² Phil Stewart, “Exclusive: Pentagon Lifts Ban on Contractors Fixing U.S.-Supplied Weapons in Ukraine,” Reuters, November 8, 2024, sec. World, reuters.com/world/pentagon-lifts-ban-contractors-inside-ukraine-fix-us-supplied-weapons-2024-11-08.

³ Jack Detsch and Paul Mcleary, “Pentagon Officials Anxious Trump May Fire the Military’s Top General,” POLITICO, November 8, 2024, politico.com/news/2024/11/08/pentagon-trump-fire-cq-brown-00188536.

Ukraine Peace: Putin Fires Missile Barrage in First Post-election Left Hook
Part IV to America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine, July 12, 2024.

Putin is probably testing President-elect Trump’s limits ahead of his designation of a U.S. Ukraine peace envoy. After surveying the situation for nearly two weeks since the U.S. election, Putin threw his first punch against the America First Peace Team by firing a large-scale missile barrage on a series of targets throughout Ukraine, including Kyiv.

  • The missile barrage was the first large-scale attack of its kind across Ukraine since late August, according to the Kyiv Independent. Zelenskyy sought to put on a brave face, stating, “Our air defenses destroyed more than 140 aerial targets.”¹

  • Overnight November 17 local time in Kyiv, Moscow launched a mix of 120 cruise and ballistic missiles, as well as 90 drones, according to President Zelenskyy. The Kyiv Independent reports hypersonic missile use and 17 Tu-95 strategic bomber sorties.²

  • Energy facilities were primary targets, and thermal plants were dealt “serious damage” resulting in emergency shutdowns, according to the country’s largest private energy company, DTEK.³

Life is Timing, and Timing is Leverage

Putin may seek to rush President Trump-elect’s decision-making on Ukraine peace envoy staffing by using these strikes as a military pressure tactic, hoping that a disorganized response would give Putin negotiating leverage. An alternative explanation is that Moscow simply wants to soften Ukrainian defenses during a Kursk counteroffensive.

  • “Trump promised to settle the Ukrainian crisis overnight. Ok, let him try. But...we understand that this will never happen,” said Gennady Gatilov, Russia’s ambassador to the United Nations in Geneva. He welcomed a negotiating process, but emphasized it must be based on “realities on the ground.”⁴

  • Russia launched a new counteroffensive on Kursk last week to take it away from Ukraine as a bargaining chip. It has also deployed at least 10,000 North Koreans to the region, according to U.S. intelligence estimates seen by the Washington Post.⁵

Region Remains on a Hair Trigger

Polish fighter aircraft scrambled to protect Polish airspace during Russia’s missile and drone barrage against Ukraine, illustrating the danger of regional miscalculation.⁶

The format of peace negotiations is beyond the scope of this white paper, which does not represent official U.S. or President-elect Trump’s policies. Its views are the author’s alone.

Sources

¹ “Kyiv Hit by First Mass Attack in 2 Months as Russia Launches Drones, Missiles at Ukraine,” The Kyiv Independent, November 17, 2024, kyivindependent.com/russia-launches-large-scale-missile-attack-on-ukraine.

² “Kyiv Hit by First Mass Attack in 2 Months as Russia Launches Drones, Missiles at Ukraine.”

³ “Russia Attacks Thermal Power Plants, Dealing ‘serious Damage,’ Operator Says,” The Kyiv Independent, November 17, 2024, kyivindependent.com/thermal-power-plant-seriously-damaged-in-russian-attack-operator-says.

⁴ “Russia Open to Any Ukraine Peace Talks If Trump Starts Them, Envoy Says | Reuters,” accessed November 17, 2024, reuters.com/world/trump-election-offers-new-possibility-us-russian-dialogue-russian-envoy-says-2024-11-14.

⁵ “Russia Wants Kursk Back Before Negotiations. Ukraine Isn’t Budging. - The Washington Post,” accessed November 17, 2024, washingtonpost.com/world/2024/11/16/russia-wants-kursk-back-before-negotiations-ukraine-isnt-budging.

⁶ Christopher Miller, “Russia Targets Ukraine Energy Sites in ‘Massive’ Missile and Drone Attack,” Financial Times, November 17, 2024, sec. War in Ukraine, ft.com/content/22d28566-79db-4aef-8cbd-493db231f19c.

Ukraine Peace: Remember Apollo
Part V to America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine, July 12, 2024.

Our peace movement faces an extraordinary moment of brinksmanship worthy of reflection. The below carefully considered words remind us of our place in the cosmos.

Sea change, see peace.¹
Question everything you know and
Step aside your escalation ladder.... Starbase Visited
Cosmonauts do not stab astronauts with pens on a leaking Space Station²
America’s Spirit and her Builders—Occupy Mars!
all else is corpse and smoke³
Pax, and Ad Astra

-NRP

¹ “Can you hope for any better vision than the sun, the moon, the stars, all the land and sea?” -Epictetus

² Joanna Thompson, “NASA Warns of Potential ‘catastrophic Failure’ on Leaking ISS — but Russia Doesn’t Want to Fix It,” livescience.com, November 22, 2024, livescience.com/space/space-exploration/nasa-warns-of-potential-catastrophic-failure-on-leaking-iss-but-russia-doesnt-want-to-fix-it.

³ Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, translated by Martin Hammond (Penguin Books, 2006), bk. 12.33.

⁴ “SpaceX’s Approach to Space Sustainability and Safety,” SpaceX, February 22, 2022, spacex.com/updates.

Ukraine Peace: Ad Astra
Part VI to America First Teaming to End the War in Ukraine, July 12, 2024.

North Korean troops fighting in Kursk and a new Iran-Russia treaty signed today continue to challenge the America First Peace Through Strength objective of ending the Ukraine war quickly.¹ We should leverage bold dealmaking momentum generated recently by the Hamas hostage release deal to (1) arrange a symbolic Trump-Putin negotiations kick-off at the Hiroshima Peace Memorial in Japan; and (2) jumpstart a quiet bilateral U.S.-Russia peace negotiations format a hemisphere away from the battlefield in Windhoek, Namibia.

From “Little Boy” to “Fat Man”

The baseline goal of ending the war in Ukraine is to prevent a thermonuclear WWIII.² All other objectives are secondary. The only places on planet earth that have suffered mass death from nuclear weapons are Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan, to conclude WWII.

The United States bombed Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, and Nagasaki three days later on August 9, 1945.³ It symbolically follows that to prevent WWIII, the public road to peace should begin in Hiroshima, and end in Nagasaki. See attached speech locales, next page.

  • President Trump should conduct a kick-off meeting with Russian President Putin at the Hiroshima Peace Memorial to somberly remind all sides of the true stakes. Mankind must make it to the stars. Mishandled, this war threatens all humanity.

  • Framing the negotiations in this context would encourage all parties to modulate missile use to prevent a nuclear weapons miscommunication or accident.

  • Geopolitically, commencing in Japan will signal U.S. desire to pivot attention toward East Asia, where China is rising. Split East-West security attention has dangerously plagued the United States for years. A Japan “opener” would clarify U.S. priorities.

  • To strengthen the U.S.-Japan alliance in the Asia Pacific, President Trump could pay homage to assassinated former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe while visiting.⁴

The Skeleton Coast

Meanwhile—before or after the public kick-off—we should establish a quiet working level in-person bilateral format between the United States and Russia far from cameras and the battlefield deep in windswept Southwest Africa: Windhoek, Namibia. Namibia is famed for its massive, empty expanses of desert, including the barren Skeleton Coast, which served as a filming location for a key shot in the recent sci-fi epic Dune: Part Two.⁵

  • Namibia is an ecotourism destination, and thus secure. Its great geographic separation from all Great Powers is the precise reason it is most apt to remove hurdles to progress. It is small, friendly, and a formally non-aligned power.⁶

This paper does not represent official U.S. or President-elect Trump’s policies. Its views are the author’s alone.

Sources

¹ “New Treaty Strengthens Iran-Russia Military Pact - Newsweek,” accessed January 17, 2025, newsweek.com/iran-russia-sign-cooperation-military-treaty-2016638.

² “2024 GOP Platform: Make America Great Again!,” July 8, 2024, 4, gop.com/press-release/icymi-rnc-platform-committee-adopts-2024-republican-party-platform.

³ “The Atomic Bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, August 1945,” National Archives, August 4, 2020, archives.gov/news/topics/hiroshima-nagasaki-75.

⁴ Brie Stimson, “Former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe Assassinated during Campaign Speech, Hospital Officials Confirm,” Fox News (Fox News, July 7, 2022), foxnews.com/world/shinzo-abe-shot-speech-former-japanese-prime-minister.

⁵ Dune: Part Two | Finding the Worlds of Dune | Warner Bros. Entertainment, 2024, youtube.com/watch.

⁶ “U.S. Relations With Namibia,” United States Department of State (blog), accessed January 17, 2025, state.gov/u-s-relations-with-namibia.

Previous
Previous

Birth Tourism: America's Citizenship Loophole and How to Close It

Next
Next

What Is in the National Interest? Hans Morgenthau’s Realist Vision and American Foreign Policy